The end of the McNabb era may have arrived

by Eric Schwartz The end of the McNabb era may have arrived thumbnail

The late Albert Einstein is known for many great pieces of knowledge. In the sports world there is one phrase he coined that seems to trump all else:

The definition of insanity is doing something over and over again and expecting a different result.”

That phrase has been used by fans over the last few seasons to persuade  the Eagles front office breaking up the duo of Donovan McNabb and Andy Reid. Of course the front office has not taken that route, keeping the pair together and hoping for different results.

As a result, the Eagles fan base has been driven insane.

The Birds made it clear earlier this season that Reid will be back, signing him to a contract extension after back-to-back wins over Washington and Atlanta. What we will soon find out is if McNabb will join him.

It’s not an easy call anyway you look at it. Few quarterbacks in the league have an arm as strong as McNabb’s. With DeSean Jackson on board McNabb got to show off that arm, throwing for over 3,5000 yards and 22 TDs. His 92.9 QB rating is well-above average.

But then there is the bounce passes and the mental lapses. And for all that he has accomplished (five NFC title games), he still has a reputation for failing to deliver in big games.

The Star-Telegram in Dallas has a good read on McNabb’s cloudy

“And while the blame for the Eagles’ 34-14 loss to Dallas on Saturday shouldn’t be laid solely at the feet of McNabb, the fact remains he is what he is — the Eagles quarterback and the face of the franchise. When things go right, he usually gets credit. When things go wrong, and wrong they did go on Saturday, McNabb must face the music and bear the brunt of the criticism, as he did Saturday.

But for how much longer?”

The rest can be read here:

With Kevin Kolb’s contract will run out after next season and Michael Vick’s option only to be picked up if he is a starter (backups don’t make $5.2 million) there is clearly a decision to be made – a decision that will go a long way in determining the teams success over the next few years.

Over the next three days I will make the case for Vick, Kolb and McNabb to be the starters, before rendering a verdict on Friday. In the meantime, who do you want to captain the Eagles next season?

Filed Under Eagles


3 Responses to “The end of the McNabb era may have arrived”

  1. BigGreek24 on January 11th, 2010 11:47 am

    Both McNabb and Kolb’s contracts run out after 2010. I’d like to see the Eagles deal McNabb and Vick, give Kolb the job and bring in a veteran backup well versed in the West Coast Offense. If nothing else, how many more seasons can McNabb put up 3500 yards and a 90+ passer rating? This was his best season since 2004.

  2. Jersey Joe on January 11th, 2010 2:34 pm

    The time has come to let McNabb go. He most likely will be a Hall of Fame Quarterback. But he will never win the Big one in an Eagles uniform. The MV signing was a mistake from the begining. Give the ball to Kolb. Find some Offensive Lineman for protection and move on.

  3. rick on January 11th, 2010 3:36 pm

    Andy said he is his guy next year so it looks like we are stuck with the “same old, same old” for next year

Got something to say?