Happ denied hardware

by Eric Schwartz Happ denied hardware thumbnail

Phillies rookie pitcher J.A, Happ was the only player named on every NL Rookie of the Year ballot by the Baseball Writers Association of America.

It still wasn’t enough to win him the award.

Florida rookie Chris Coghlan received 17 first-place votes, to Happ’s 10 in winning the award, Major League Baseball announced today.

To his credit Coghlan did have strong credentials, batting .321 with 31 doubles and nine home runs with the Marlins. However, I’m still not sure he deserved the nod over Happ, who was a big reason why the Phillies made it to the World Series for the second-straight season.

In his first full season Happ was sensational going 12-4 with a 2.93 ERA in 23 starts. He was certainly the best rookie pitcher leading all NL rookies in innings (166), strikeouts (119) and complete games (three).

He also appeared in 12 games as a reliever, most coming early in the season when Chan Ho Park was starting, and a few coming in the playoffs when the team needed someone reliable to give them innings.

Happ was a consistent pitcher on a staff that often lacked it. He jus didn’t get the hardware he deserved.

Filed Under Phillies

Comments

2 Responses to “Happ denied hardware”

  1. Joseph Birmingham on November 16th, 2009 5:03 pm

    should have gone to Happ, anytime player left out on nearly 1/4 of the ballots, and another player is 1st, 2nd or 3rd on EVERY ballot, it seems obvious who the ROY is. Great year JA, dont worry you get no respect, you are a true Phillie now !!

  2. BigGreek24 on November 16th, 2009 5:28 pm

    What was really pissing me off this morning was the guys on XM. They kept saying that their pick was Hansen. They basically dismissed Happ which I didn’t get. Happ made one more start, one won more game and had an era of 2.93 against Hansen’s 2.89. Not sure which pitcher had the better whip. I’m not upset that Coghlin won – he was an everyday player once he was called up and he led the NL with 113 hits in the second half which is pretty impressive. Had Hansen won I’d have been very disappointed.

Got something to say?